Explore by State
New Jersey Home
Historic Site

First Presbyterian Church and Elizabethtown Academy

New Jersey
42 Broad Street Elizabeth, NJ 07201
Share
Elizabeth, NJ

First Presbyterian Church, Burial Grounds and Elizabethtown Academy

Historical Marker Database

The First Presbyterian Church, established on the site of the original meetinghouse around 1664, was one of the targets of British attacks on Elizabeth in January 1780. Pastor James Caldwell, known as the “Fighting Parson,” and many congregation members supported the Patriot cause. Tragically, Caldwell's wife, Hannah Ogden Caldwell, was killed by a British/Hessian soldier during the Battle of Connecticut Farms in 1780 — an event that shocked New Jersey and helped galvanize Patriot resistance, and Caldwell was killed a year and a half later. Both are buried in the cemetery alongside many other Revolutionary War veterans.

By the 1750s, the demand for and interest in secondary education led church leaders to establish a modest school called the "Academy," located about 200 yards from the church. Notable figures, including Aaron Burr,  Alexander Hamilton, and Supreme Court Justice Brokholt Livingston, were among the Academy's first pupils. On January 25, 1780, the Academy was raided and burned. The building that stands on the site today, built in 1917, recently reopened as a museum, cultural center, and community hub. 

What's Nearby

Explore more of The Liberty Trail by visiting these nearby attractions.

0
First Presbyterian Church and Elizabethtown Academy
0.086509865152532
Cannon at Elizabeth Courthouse
0.16896096153814
Saint John’s Episcopal Church
0.46174827920291
Boxwood Hall State Historic Site
0.54473751556235
Nathaniel Bonnell House
1.1738300645465
Minuteman Statue
Historic Site
|
Historic House
Exterior of Liberty Hall from the Visit Elizabeth website
Liberty Hall

Union, NJ 07083

Former home of NJ's first elected governor

2.1432540027059
Liberty Hall
2.1432540027059
Battle of Connecticut Farms and Liberty Hall Museum
2.9825457831157
Elizabethtown Point
5.8467944277139
Union Veterans Honor Roll Park
5.885143226646
Connecticut Farms and Springfield
6.4279518945101
Caldwell Parsonage
7.3829401818742
Lafayette Tour Marker, Staten Island, New York (NY-120)
8.8744061303438
Col. Israel Angell Memorial and Rahway River Bridge
9.0929478234571
Vauxhall Bridge Battle Marker
9.2454619993533
Hessian House
9.3245006944229
Cannonball House at Springfield Battlesite
9.3245006944229
Cannonball House at Springfield Battle Site
9.357072386211
Military Park
9.6317569203502
Springfield Presbyterian Church
10.178618349848
Battle of Springfield
10.19399391913
Taylor Park and the Forgotten Victory Trail
10.398130519938
Last British Thrust Marker
14.49997711958
The Battle of Short Hills
Historic Site
Shot of Fort Wadsworth overlooking the waters of New York
Fort Wadsworth

Staten Island, NY 10305

Historic Fort under British Occupation 1776-1783

14.794845916111
Fort Wadsworth
15.529136985684
Stage House Inn
State/County Park
|
Battlefield
Photo of DAR monument commemorating the Battle of Paulus Hook in Paulus Hook Park
Paulus Hook

Jersey City, NJ 07302

Patriot morale is restored in New Jersey

16.092203380665
Paulus Hook
17.793203292293
Fraunces Tavern Museum
National Park
|
Historic Site
Federal Hall in New York City
Federal Hall

New York, NY 10005

Site where Washington took the first oath of office

17.983223425704
Federal Hall | National Memorial New York
Historic Site
|
Historic House
Proprietary House
Governor's Mansion

Perth Amboy, NJ 08861

Mansion of Benjamin Franklin's Loyalist son, William

18.290196152306
Royal Governor's Mansion
18.625831604237
The Green-Wood Cemetery
18.712354678327
Four Chimneys Marker
Historic Site
|
Historic House
Nathaniel Drake House Exterior
Drake House

Plainfield, NJ 07060

Washington's HQ prior to the battle of Short Hills

19.067678926007
Nathaniel Drake House
19.136191867535
Center for Brooklyn History
Historic Site
|
Historic House
Old Stone House photographed by Jay Ruffins
Old Stone House

Brooklyn, NY 11215

Explore Revolution Brooklyn from 1776 - 1783

19.50065367809
Old Stone House
Historic Site
|
Museum
Photograph of the front of the Brooklyn Museum
Brooklyn Museum

Brooklyn, NY 11238

Museum in Brooklyn with Rev War collections

21.246116859398
Brooklyn Museum
25.84291062987
New Jersey Brigade Area
National Park
|
Historic House
Ford Mansion

Morristown, NJ 07960

25.864109759712
Ford Mansion
26.687844236691
Cornelius Low House
26.758564593505
Lord Stirling's Manor Site
Battlefield
Detail from an engraving of the Battle of Harlem Heights
Harlem Heights

New York, NY 10027

Confident British forces are checked in battle

26.789230049982
Harlem Heights
26.838646760362
Buccleuch Mansion
26.871129099343
First Presbyterian Church
Historic Site
|
Gardens & Grounds
Washington, Hamilton, and Lafayette on the Morristown Green
Morristown Green

Morristown, NJ 07960

Where France committed to the cause of Independence

26.902775866373
Morristown Green
Historic Site
Historic Depiction of Arnold's Tavern in Morristown New Jersey
Arnold's Tavern

Morristown, NJ 07960

Washington's HQ for the first Morristown encampment

26.972556799431
Arnold's Tavern
National Park
|
Fort/Outpost
View from a gun position at Fort Nonsense, Morristown NPS
Fort Nonsense

Morristown, NJ 07960

27.184916748507
Fort Nonsense
27.583748100198
East Jersey Old Town Village
State/County Park
|
Historic House
Dey Mansion with overcast sky
Dey Mansion

Wayne, NJ 07470

Washington's HQ before the winter camp at Morristown

28.353244617153
Dey Mansion
28.599182049618
Abraham Staats House
Historic Site
|
Historic House
Abraham Staats House, located in South Bound Brook, NJ
Staats House

South Bound Brook, NJ 08880

Von Steuben's Middlebrook HQ that hosted Washington

28.599182049618
Staats House
Historic Site
|
Historic House
Facade of Hamilton Grange
Hamilton Grange

New York, NY 10005

Home of Founding Father, Alexander Hamilton

28.656246396506
Hamilton Grange
Historic Site
|
National Park
1760s era lighthouse located at the Gateway National Recreational Area in Sandy Hook
Sandy Hook

Highlands, NJ 07732

Strategic fortified lighthouse used by Loyalists

28.719516812671
Sandy Hook
National Park
|
Historic Site
Morristown

Morristown, NJ 07960

Site of two Continental winter encampments

29.062600439802
Morristown
National Park
|
Historic Site
The Wick House at Jockey Hollow in Morristown
Jockey Hollow

Morristown, NJ 07960

29.69100690206
Jockey Hollow
30.133899877409
Morris Jumel Mansion
Battlefield
|
Fort/Outpost
Cannons at Fort Lee Historical Park facing the George Washington Bridge
Fort Lee

Fort Lee, NJ 07024

Cornwallis pushes American forces into New Jersey

30.695667268885
Fort Lee
Battlefield
View towards former location of Fort Washington
Fort Washington

New York, NY 10033

Last American stronghold of Manhattan

31.547354048079
Fort Washington
Historic Site
|
Historic House
The Zabriskie-Steuben house at Historic New Bridge Landing
New Bridge

River Edge, NJ 07661

Site along Washington's Retreat route from NY

31.903452236029
Historic New Bridge Landing